מאחר ואפילו אני לא הבנתי מה שיצא לי בעברית, מחקתי וכתבתי באנגלית
Since he who has no existence, can not be asked to choose whether to exist or not, this is a moot question but for the sake of conducting a philosophical exercise, assuming this was indeed possible, do you have any doubt in your mind you would have said “Yes, I wish to be born?”
I think what you are inferring to, is a wish to be able and choose different "playing cards" than the one you got handed when you were born. Perhaps to be born into a different background or family, perhaps to be granted a different level of conscious or awareness, personality etc., all leading to you making different choices in life, and ultimately ending up in a different state than your current one.
מאחר ואפילו אני לא הבנתי מה שיצא לי בעברית, מחקתי וכתבתי באנגלית
Since he who has no existence, can not be asked to choose whether to exist or not, this is a moot question but for the sake of conducting a philosophical exercise, assuming this was indeed possible, do you have any doubt in your mind you would have said “Yes, I wish to be born?”
I think what you are inferring to, is a wish to be able and choose different "playing cards" than the one you got handed when you were born. Perhaps to be born into a different background or family, perhaps to be granted a different level of conscious or awareness, personality etc., all leading to you making different choices in life, and ultimately ending up in a different state than your current one.
תגובות (12)
נא להתחבר כדי להגיב
התחברות או הרשמה
/null/text_64k_1#
איפה באמת?
לא הייתי בוחרת משהו אחר.. כמו שאמא שלי אומרת לא מחליפים את השק שלך עם שק של אף אחד אחר..
מי
ומה אני
תוהות ,הבראות
אין תשובה
לא נשאלתי
להיות או
לא-להיו-ת.
ולהפסיד את כל זה? אין מצב.. ברור שהייתי בוחרת להוולד
לא.. לא הייתי בוחרת להיות מישהו אחר
מה היית בוחרת אם היו שואלים?
I think what you are inferring to, is a wish to be able and choose different "playing cards" than the one you got handed when you were born. Perhaps to be born into a different background or family, perhaps to be granted a different level of conscious or awareness, personality etc., all leading to you making different choices in life, and ultimately ending up in a different state than your current one.
כן ולא את ולא זוכרים כי דואגים להשכיח את זה מאיתנו.
(מתארת לעצמי שהיית מעדיפה תשובות מתחכמות יותר. סורי אין לי. האמת לא מתחכמת. היא אמת.)